Press Releases Scotland's Economy

Business for Scotland criticises CBI Scotland’s call for more austerity

Screenshot 2015-05-08 16.54.05

Or hopefully not with 56 SNP MPs

New CBI Scotland Director Hugh Aitken’s calls for austerity to be a priority for the new SNP MPs have been criticised by Business for Scotland.

In his statement on the SNP election performance, Mr Aitken said: “Getting the deficit down must be a priority, to maintain the UK’s credibility in international markets which will keep the cost of borrowing down for growing Scottish businesses.”

The CBI is therefore effectively calling for austerity to be a priority.  Austerity was rejected en masse by the Scottish electorate by returning 56 out of 59 MPs on platform of investing in growth and job creation rather than more cuts. Business for Scotland believes the SNP should make Full Fiscal Responsibility and more powers a priority.

Credibility in international markets will be driven by growth, job creation, increased exports and the resultant reduction in the demand for welfare, which will reduce the deficit on a % of GDP basis and allow for longer term more sustainable and less socially harmful fiscal management.

Austerity has been criticised recently by leading economists such as Professor Steve Keen and Nobel prize winner Paul Krugman. The CBI’s call for austerity measures to be implemented in Scotland would slow down Scotland’s economic growth, damage credibility in international markets and could increase the cost of borrowing for business across the UK and reduce cashflow.

Gordon MacIntyre-Kemp CEO of Business for Scotland said: “One thing is clear, with each of the three parties that support austerity reduced to only one MP each, Westminster has no mandate to implement austerity upon Scotland. Scotland needs to powers to invest in economic growth and job creation.

“The CBI’s support for austerity would be counterproductive and is out of step with the business and political mood in Scotland.”

Scottish economy could double with Fiscal Autonomy 

150 Business People Declare Support for Full Fiscal Responsibility

Leading economist attacks austerity, praising Greens and SNP

See CBI Comments here: 

Business for Scotland – Prosperity for Scotland – Join us now


About the author

Michelle Rodger

Michelle is a former national newspaper journalist who co-founded an award-winning IT business before launching Tartan Cat Communications. A social media and crowdfunding expert she manages media and communications for Business for Scotland.

1 Comment

  • Mr Aitken clearly lives in that parallel universe which is also inhabited by the current – and previous – Tory government.

    In that universe, the rich get richer and austerity is only for those less advantaged in society.

    The CBI has long been a mouthpiece for the Tory Party as this statement from Mr Aitken further demonstrates.

    What irks me is organisations funded by tax-payers money – such as the BBC – are members of the CBI and as a consequence their claims to provide objective new reporting are just that, claims.

    I would suggest Mr Aitken looks at those economies of a similar size to Scotland’s – Norway, Sweden, Denmark, etc. – where so-called austerity policies have been largely discredited and where government and business are now focused on Keynesian policies to stimulate economic growth via public works, stimulating consumer demand, etc.

    Not surprisingly those economies are outperforming the UK and Scotland.

    Regurgitating Tory dogma is now what CBI members pay their dues for then again perhaps it is.


    Alistair Grant

Leave a Comment